Wednesday, 26 February 2014

An attempt to explain Europe

Europe is like a Russian doll. Really. But that doesn't mean Russia is part of Europe. And what about its former satellites? The Baltics are part of the European Union, so they are now firmly "in Europe" - but the future of Ukraine is not so clear.

Here is my attempt to explain how Europe, the European Union and the Euro differ from each other but are all related to each other. And all are subject to change.





Related reading (suggested by Twitter followers):

Does Central Europe exist? - Timothy Garton Ash
The puzzle of Central Europe - Timothy Garton Ash
Europe: A History - Norman Davies (book)
Europe Europe - Enzensberger (book)
Also Patrick Leigh Fermoy's books.

17 comments:

  1. Timothy Garton Ash is good on this (and much else) - two essays worth reading (though alas paywalled) are this from 1986 http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/1986/oct/09/does-central-europe-exist/ together with a later reflection from the very different perspective of 1999 http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/1986/oct/09/does-central-europe-exist/

    More lightheartedly, the question where the actual centre of Europe might be is much disputed - but with a counter-intuitively strong candidate in Lithuania http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centre_of_Europe

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Stefan. Links are not live in comments, so I have reposted your links in the Related Reading section.

      Delete
  2. Frances

    Thank you for trying to explain our strange european (geografically speaking)/ European (politically speaking) ways to our non-european friends.

    You where right the other day; many Americans seem to ignore/ overlook the deep historical scars and bonds of this continent, dismissing them as whims. To be fair, we too once in a while just can't follow the internal politics of US, or China for that matter.

    Posts like yours enlighten us all.

    By the way, your post on pound sterling, it was awesome, too.

    Regards

    ReplyDelete
  3. Canada is a wonderful country in the world.Many are people visited canda of every year with their family.But visited for Canada want`s a legal visa.Canada super visa give you legal visa.If you have face any problem we are give cash back to you.So you can visit our site. For more information Super Visa Insurance

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry, we're (mostly) Brits. We don't need visas, even spam ones, to visit Canada. Very thick wooly jumpers, certainly, but not visas.

      Delete
  4. "For example, consider a chart showing the relative economic performance of the US, the UK, the EU and Japan (I see a lot of these!). This is meaningless. The UK is part of the EU. It can’t be “compared” with it."

    I'm not sure that is true. If you want to know how the UK is doing compared to the EU average, then you have to compare the UK to the EU. If you wanted to, you could also compare the UK to the EU ex-UK, and I don't think you would get a very different answer. You can of course compare any EU member with the EU average. For example, the tragic situation of Italy, which used to have GDP/head 15% above the EU average, and has now fallen to parity.

    And by the way, I don't think that comparing how the UK is doing to how the EU is doing is just a question of proving a point. I can remember when the UK's GDP/head was down around 60% of Germany's, back around 1980, and today it's roughly equal on a nominal basis and 94% of Germany's on a PPP basis, so relative performance really does move around.

    Oh, and calling the Great War a "family feud" was a joke, right? At least I hope you were joking.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Obviously it is possible to compare the UK with the EU average. But that is not what I am talking about. I am talking about charts that show 4 bars, one each for US, UK, EU and Japan. When I look into what these charts ACTUALLY show, they are nearly always confusing the EU with the Euro area. Typically it is a monetary policy comparison (hence the choice of countries).

      It was only partly a joke. Did you see the BBC's programme on the relationship between Kaiser Wilhelm, Tsar Nicholas and George V - who were, of course, all Queen Victoria's grandchildren?

      Delete
    2. "When I look into what these charts ACTUALLY show, they are nearly always confusing the EU with the Euro area."

      That's a better point, but it isn't exactly what you originally said. On the question of the three monarchs, of course they were closely related - and God help us, are we really living in an age where we have to see a BBC program to know that? - but that had very little to do with the origins of the War.

      What drove the outbreak of the war was that 1916 was the last date the Schlieffen Plan had a chance to succeed. Schleiffen proposed that Germany could win a two front war with Russia and France, by taking them out in succession France first and then Russia. In other words, a two front war, one front at a time.

      But that depended on Russia being able to mobilize only slowly, in months, while Germany and France could mobilize in a couple of weeks. So 90% of the German army would defeat France, and then move East to defeat Russia. But then Russia started to modernize its rail network, and by 1916 would have been able to mobilize significantly faster, leading to an un-winnable simultaneous two front war for Germany.

      Hence the urgency to get a war started before 1916, which was the last date by which the Kaiser's Generals could guarantee a German victory.

      In the event, the Russians sacrificed themselves by invading East Prussia with only a partial mobilization, and suffered a terrible defeat in the process - so bad that the Russian commander, Samsonov, committed suicide - but the German staff panicked and transferred troops form the Western front to the East, which arguably saved the French.

      Really, the three countries could have been Republics or Islamic Califates, and the same strategic logic would have held.

      Delete
    3. Jon,

      It is what I said, actually. You chose not to understand.

      Your potted history of WW1 is very interesting but takes absolutely no account of the long political buildup before it, which is what I was talking about. It's a bit like describing the last few days before the fall of Lehman while ignoring the previous two years of developing strains in the financial system. It's true, but inadequate.

      Delete
  5. I'm still surprised at how much of this isn't common knowledge. A Canadian colleague - well educated and generally knowledgeable - was surprised yesterday to hear the Euro wasn't compulsory throughout the European Union. When I pointed out that the UK didn't use it, he asked "Britain's not part of the EU though, is it?"

    I know very few people who are current with the make-up of the EU to the West of Germany and Italy.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Alex, thank you for saying this. It was the reason why I wrote the post.

      Delete
  6. If you are looking for a Software Development Company in Delhi you can check this site http://www.acetechindia.com/

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. In practice the case of the Ukraine could be about the Eurasian Union and maybe a currency union. 2015 is the date and some people think 2017 maybe the Currency Union - not sure about that. I see what happens in the Ukraine as a certain kind of positioning before the go-live.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Canada is a wonderful country in the world. Here are many beautiful and charming place.Many are people visited Canada of every year. If you can visit here must be you should take visa. we are give you visa on granti. If you have face any problem we are give you cash back with 100 percent sure.For more you can visit our website: Super Visa Insurance Canada

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hi Frances Coppola!
    I visited your blog which are very interesting. I feel you have great collection and positive thinking of you that you have shared all updates and useful contents shared here. You have done good job. Keep it up. i am also working in immigration department and help out in any type of visa application's like Green Card Petition for Spouse, Houston Immigration Lawyer Finance Visa Requirements, K1 Fiance Visa Attorney, US Citizenship Marriage,

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thank you for trying to explain our strange european (geografically speaking)/ European (politically speaking) ways to our non-european friends.
    Agen Poker Online Indonesia Terpercaya

    ReplyDelete